Celera and Science (Magazine) and Publication Policy, correspondence, 2000
Scope and Contents
Correspondence with NHGRI staff regarding a letter sent to both J. Craig Venter and Francis Collins from Science. Because of the media's attention to the competitive "race" between the Human Genome Project and Celera, and the data reaching public news outlets instead of a peer reviewed journal, there was a risk of the collapse of collegiality that could be detrimental to the science community, according to Science. Therefore, the journal hoped to publish the findings of HGP and Celera in one single Science issue, and encouraged both parties not to give negative feedback about one another to the press. Documents include this letter, along with correspondence with Francis Collins, Mike Dexter, Michael Morgan, Martin Bobrow, and John Sulston. Francis, Michael, Mike, Martin, and John drafted a letter to send to Science out of concern that they had not seen Celera's data yet, and they did not want this collaboration to prevent HGP from releasing their data without restrictions. Francis was hesitant about sending the letter because he had been told from very high people not to do anything that would look like an attempt to stop Celera from publishing their data. Documents also include an article from The Scientist from March 2000 warning the dangers of bypassing Peer Reviews and taking scientific data straight to news outlets. In the article, Francis Collins called this "regrettable" and suggested that scientists were doing so in the genomic field because the findings were perceived as having business value.
Dates
- Creation: 2000
Conditions Governing Access
This collection may contain materials with sensitive or confidential individual and patient information, as well as sensitive information about the grant funding process, that is protected under federal or state right to privacy laws and regulations. As such we are unable to make fully available publicly much of these materials. Those that have been made available have been carefully redacted so as to remove all personally identifiable information (PII).
Researchers can request access to items through this site but should be aware that many items will require extensive redactions, or in some cases will be unable to be made available. In these cases, NHGRI History of Genomics staff will work with researchers as much as possible to fullfill requests but we cannot guarantee full compliance with every request.
Extent
From the Collection: 98 Box (98 boxes of papers, books, brochures and other printed materials.)
Language of Materials
From the Collection: English
Repository Details
Part of the NHGRI Human Genome Project (HGP) Archive Repository
Building 31, Room 4B09
31 Center Drive, MSC 2152
9000 Rockville Pike
Bethesda Maryland 20892 USA
zach.utz@nih.gov