Letter from Thomas Schneider (on behalf of Celera) to President Clinton critical of public HGP, and related NHGRI correspondence, 1999 - 2000
Scope and Contents
A letter from Thomas J. Schneider, who was on the board of trustees for the Institute for Genome Research, to President Clinton on January 27, 1999 after NIH and Francis Collins rejected the Memorandum of Understanding FOE created for Celera and NIH. Schneider called this rejection of the MOU "professional jealousy" and asked President Clinton to step in and help. A second letter was sent from Thomas J. Schneider to President Bill Clinton on March 28, 2000 after President Clinton held a joint statement with Tony Blair on free access to genomic information on March 13th. Thomas Schneider argued that by doing so it made the private sector look evil, meanwhile the biotechnology market dropped by at least 100 billion dollars, because President Clinton's statements created uncertainty and caused the flight of capital. To Schneider, without private money for research, everything would get done at a slower pace, and waiting to publish data until the genome was fully sequenced meant the quality of the information would be better, rather than sloppy unfinished data. Schneider encouraged President Clinton to reach out to Craig Ventor because he had quality in his work and Celera would sequence the human genome before HGP, despite what Francis Collins might say. This version of the letter also has Francis Collins' handwritten notes in the margins disagreeing with a lot of the letter. Documents also include a draft of a response from Francis Collins to Thomas Schneider, and correspondence from Francis Collins to staff over fear of the polarization of public and private efforts in genomics as portrayed in the press, and a desire for a subcommittee of their Advisory Council to provide advice on maximizing the benefits of the interface between NIH and the pharmaceutical sectors.
Dates
- Creation: 1999 - 2000
Conditions Governing Access
This collection may contain materials with sensitive or confidential individual and patient information, as well as sensitive information about the grant funding process, that is protected under federal or state right to privacy laws and regulations. As such we are unable to make fully available publicly much of these materials. Those that have been made available have been carefully redacted so as to remove all personally identifiable information (PII).
Researchers can request access to items through this site but should be aware that many items will require extensive redactions, or in some cases will be unable to be made available. In these cases, NHGRI History of Genomics staff will work with researchers as much as possible to fullfill requests but we cannot guarantee full compliance with every request.
Extent
From the Collection: 98 Box (98 boxes of papers, books, brochures and other printed materials.)
Language of Materials
From the Collection: English
Repository Details
Part of the NHGRI Human Genome Project (HGP) Archive Repository
Building 31, Room 4B09
31 Center Drive, MSC 2152
9000 Rockville Pike
Bethesda Maryland 20892 USA
zach.utz@nih.gov